Speaking Confidence Needs More Practice
Knowing an answer and feeling ready to say it aloud are different things. Research reported on November 16 has drawn attention to students’ confidence in public speaking. Speakers Trust, a British charity, found that fewer than 22 percent of pupils surveyed through its work felt confident speaking in front of a group. Its report draws on work with 213,355 students over seven years. The responses came from pupils involved in its speaking workshops, rather than a national sample chosen at random. The findings therefore should not be treated as a measure of every student’s confidence. The charity is calling for speaking confidence to be measured annually, so schools can identify differences and check whether support is helping.
That proposal raises questions about how schools should teach and assess speaking. A student might understand a subject well but struggle to explain it to an audience. Another might speak confidently without giving a clear answer. Confidence and ability therefore need separate attention. Teachers could offer practice in pairs before asking students to address larger groups. Helpful feedback could focus on organising ideas and making a point clearly, rather than simply speaking loudly. However, turning confidence into another score could create pressure for students who already dislike presentations. Schools would need to decide how to collect useful information without making pupils feel labelled. For adult learners, similar questions arise in meetings, interviews and language classes. The challenge is to create opportunities to speak while allowing people to build confidence at different speeds.
—
Chat
Talk about these words from the article.
aloud / confidence / public speaking / charity / surveyed / workshops / national sample / at random / annually / assess / audience / ability / feedback / presentations / labelled
—
Discussion
In what situations do you feel most comfortable speaking English?
What makes speaking to a group different from speaking to one person?
How can someone be knowledgeable but still find presentations difficult?
What kind of feedback helps you feel more willing to speak?
How should schools measure progress in speaking?
What problems could arise from giving students a confidence score?
How can teachers or managers encourage quieter people to contribute?
What small speaking challenge would you like to try, and how would you prepare?